More than a decade of grousing about product management

Engineering Needs the Whole Product Picture

Whole Product
There are many pieces to the whole product

Engineers dismissing valuable product features as irrelevant to sales can hinder product development and competitiveness.

Five little words. “That feature doesn’t sell products“. Seems innocuous enough, but it is the death of product development when uttered by engineering.

Marketing is tasked with defining what a product should do, what features are needed, and how to compare/differentiate with competitors. We write requirements and guide them into the development process.

All to have engineering remove features that they don’t believe drive value. Unfortunately, engineering doesn’t know the concept of “whole product“. That beyond the core widget are the services and traits of the product that extend the offering, and provide the unique value proposition, thus enticing the customer to part with their folding money on your product or service.

What it boils down to is that engineering doesn’t understand that when all the competitors have a feature (from the cheap knock offs up to the best-in-class products) that it no longer is optional, but the table stakes to play in the game.

While engineering may be technically correct, that feature X is not the reason why people will buy your product, what they fail to realize is that not having it may be the reason to buy the competitor.

An example: When people are buying a car, rarely do they consider something like a full-size spare tire as a must have. But not having a spare tire at all? That would indeed prevent a rational person from buying a car (unless the car had “run flat” tires). No amount of horsepower, or V8 engine, or cool gadgetry will get around that deficiency.

When you are entering a new market, with a new product, where there are already established players, you must not assume that you can disrupt the “Expected Product” because of one singular dimension that you are superior. That might spark interest, but it is never enough on its own.

The lessons of the Whole Product, the Expected Product (aka the table stakes to play), and the Extended Product (differentiators that make the product easier to choose) are clear.


Those five little words should not be accepted without challenge. We are trusted to push back, to develop a whole product strategy, and to be constantly on the lookout for how to expand the ecosystem of the product with features, services, and other ways to become a leader, instead of a follower.

Written by

A crusty veteran from the product management trenches. Plenty of salty language, references to cannabis, and a connoisseur of White Russian cocktails

View all articles
Leave a reply

Written by pmdude